Why We Play What Everyone Else Is Playing

By Alex╺

  • PS4
  • PS5
  • XBox One
  • Series X
  • PC

Why We Play What Everyone Else Is Playing

A game can attract thousands of players before anyone knows whether it’s any good. So what makes people follow the crowd, and how much does popularity influence what we play?

You’ve got an hour to play something, but you haven’t decided what. You open the player charts and start scrolling. There’s a game with 200 players, and also a game you’ve never heard of before which has 200,000 people online, so you click through to see what all the fuss is about. You haven’t watched a trailer or read a review yet, but those 200,000 players have already influenced your decision.

There’s a reason we pay attention to what everyone else is playing. A large audience gives us a starting point when we’re looking for entertainment, particularly when we have hundreds of games to choose from. But what makes those numbers so persuasive?

Choosing a game becomes difficult when the selection is enormous. Steam has thousands of titles competing for attention, and a player who opens the store without a particular game in mind needs somewhere to begin. Popularity charts provide that starting point because other people’s choices have already narrowed the search.

The same problem appears in online casino gaming. A New Zealand player browsing the 5,000-plus games on SpinBet Casino encounters an extensive pokies catalogue alongside table games.

Recognisable titles, including Gates of Olympus 1000 and Sugar Rush 1000, give players something specific to investigate without working through the entire selection.

There’s a practical reason for paying attention to what other people play. Popularity suggests that a game has attracted an audience, which is useful information when you’re deciding where to spend your free time.

Steam’s player charts make that information particularly visible. PUBG: Battlegrounds reached a peak of 3,257,248 concurrent players on Steam, while Palworld recorded 2,101,867.

Those figures describe extraordinary levels of participation, although they cannot tell us whether either game will suit someone encountering it for the first time.

Following the Crowd Is a Human Habit

Psychologists call this social proof. When we’re uncertain about a choice, we pay attention to what other people have chosen. It’s a useful shortcut when investigating every available option would take longer than the entertainment itself.

In a 2012 study on Quantifying Social Influence in an Online Cultural Market, MIT researchers Coco Krumme and colleagues analysed an experiment involving approximately 14,000 people choosing among 48 unfamiliar songs.

Participants who could see other people’s download counts were influenced by those numbers when deciding what to sample. Once they had listened, their own assessment became more important.

Gaming presents a similar decision. A large player count encourages you to investigate a title, but playing it gives you information that popularity charts cannot provide.

There’s also a practical advantage to joining an established multiplayer game. An active community means you have people available to play with, rather than waiting for enough participants to start a match.

A Game Becomes More Than Something You Play

Gaming popularity also develops outside the game itself. Someone watches a creator playing an unfamiliar title, shares the video with friends and discovers that the game has become a regular subject of conversation.

Roblox provides an excellent example. In YouTube’s December 2025 year-end review, Culture & Trends Manager Maddy Buxton identified Grow a Garden, Dandy’s World, Forsaken and Steal a Brainrot among the year’s trending topics in the United States.

These are user-created Roblox experiences that attracted attention beyond their immediate player communities. Videos introduced the games to audiences who had never played them, while creators gave viewers reasons to follow what was happening.

YouTube’s Global Director of Culture & Trends, Kevin Allocca, made an observation about online video culture in a 2023 discussion of popular content:

“These videos are not just things you watch, they’re things… you want to discuss and unpack [and] go beyond the standard viewing experience”.

His point concerns participation. Viewers discuss content, share it and become involved in the communities surrounding it.

Gaming videos work particularly well in that environment because watching someone play can encourage viewers to join the activity themselves.

A popular game therefore gains attention from people who have never opened it. By the time they decide to play, they may already know its characters or recognise the jokes circulating around it.

Player Numbers Need Some Context

Player counts are useful, provided you understand what they’re measuring. A game’s lifetime audience tells a different story from the number of people playing at this particular moment.

Consider Minecraft. Its worldwide audience is enormous, yet an individual Minecraft server can struggle to accommodate a few dozen active players. The number of people a server can handle depends on its hardware and the work required to keep the game running.

An individual server with 20 players exploring separate parts of the world can face a heavier workload than one with 20 players gathered in the same area. The technical explanation is covered in this guide to Minecraft server capacity.

Different statistics answer different questions:

StatisticWhat It Measures
Total playersThe wider audience that has played a game
Concurrent playersPeople playing simultaneously
Server populationPlayers connected to a particular server
Historical peakThe highest recorded concurrent audience

These distinctions become important when interpreting popularity charts. A game with a spectacular launch-day peak may have a smaller active community today, while another title attracts a steady audience without ever breaking records.

For multiplayer games, the current population is particularly useful because it tells you whether other people are available to play.

Popularity Helps Narrow the Choice

Popularity becomes less useful once you know what kind of experience you want. Someone interested in competitive multiplayer matches has different priorities from someone who wants to spend half an hour playing a single-player game.

Casino gaming involves a similar decision. Whether you choose options like live casino games, blackjack or roulette, the final route lies on what you actually enjoy, not just the size of the audience.

Three considerations help when choosing something new:

  1. Recognisable titles provide a starting point when you’re unfamiliar with a large catalogue.
  2. Game format determines whether the experience involves other participants or individual play.
  3. Personal enjoyment decides whether the game deserves another session.

Those features give players additional information about the available entertainment, although promotional activity tells us nothing about whether a particular game will suit their preferences.

This brings us back to the distinction identified in the MIT experiment. Other people’s choices can encourage us to investigate something, but we still have to decide whether we enjoy it.

The Crowd Can Point You Toward a Game

Return to those two games you noticed at the beginning. One has 200 players online, while the other has 200,000. There’s a good chance you’ll investigate the bigger game first because its audience has already given you a reason to be curious.

That decision is perfectly reasonable. Player counts tell us something useful about participation, particularly when we’re interested in joining an active community. Gaming videos and conversations with friends add further information about what people are enjoying.

But popularity only gets the investigation started. Once you’ve played for yourself, you have something better than a number on a screen: your own experience.

The game with 200,000 players may turn out to be your new favourite, or you might discover that a smaller game suits you better. Either way, the crowd helped you decide where to begin; the final decision is yours.

18+ only. Gambling should remain entertainment. Set personal spending limits, play responsibly and never gamble with money you cannot afford to lose.